A terrible reality that isn’t technically “real”, but which represents an undesirable, regressive future. Like a simulation, you could say. Or a nightmare. I have actual truck loads of evidence for this. There’s lots more to come in future parts. For now, I will share why I am very convinced that Moftiss have covertly inserted a dystopian tale into the 4th act of this five-act series. It would explain the extremely confusing (opposite, in fact) characterization (like John), Mary’s redemption, and the removal of the romance and chemistry from the show. A nightmare. Possibly our nightmare more than Sherlock’s.
It seemed like they were telling a different story because they were telling a different story, a “What if?”. What if heteronormativity and homophobia won? What if not only the love story failed to come to fruition, but the love story never even existed.
I hear you asking already; what would be the point of that? I came across this:
“Many novels combine both [utopia and dystopia], often as a metaphor for the different directions humanity can take, depending on its choices, ending up with one of two possible futures.”x
Without yet having the final and fifth act to give the fourth series meaning, it makes one hell of a stressful puzzle to be left with for a hiatus. It’s a puzzle, because it’s a dystopia that’s missing it’s counterpart, the utopia.
I just want to point out something to those of us who haven’t waited years between episodes of Sherlock. The time between Episode 3 and Episode 4 was two years, meaning fans had to wait TWO YEARS to find out what happened to Sherlock and John at the pool with Moriarty. There was a massive cliffhanger and then fans WAITED and then it turned out to be nothing of importance. What a let down! Oh but wait! That’s exactly what happened between episodes 6 and 7. Sherlock fell, but he survived somehow, and then fans waited TWO YEARS to find out how, but it didn’t matter how because the massive cliffhanger was nothing of importance. AND THEN they DID IT AGAIN between episodes 9, 10, and 11, spanning THREE YEARS and the Moriarty’s return massive cliffhanger turned out to be NOTHING.
Friendly reminder that your Tumblr experience is directly related to which blogs you follow, so with that in mind I am openly telling you that I am super excited about BBC Sherlock, I love it, I can’t wait for what happens with it in the future, I believe in a long game with every ounce of my being, and even though I’m wrong about all sorts of theories I write, I will continue to write and believe in them because being a theorist for BBC Sherlock has been the most fun thing in my life and I wouldn’t trade it for the world. I love getting hyped for no reason, I love going to conventions, I love meeting other Johnlockers, I love it all. I will get excited come Christmastime, however misguided that may be because it is fun. It is fun to theorize, it is fun to guess, and I have fun even being wrong. So there. I’ll be over here having fun if anyone cares to join me.
Today in class my professor was talking about writing cliches and she mentioned how saying someone was “brutally murdered” is one of her pet peeves and she was like “Is it even possible to murder someone nicely?”
And I was mentally like well yes according to Steven Moffat and Mark Gatiss
Oh, I agree completely. Someone picks up the bust, the AGRA memory stick is immediately out of the bust. It is quite stupid, right?
Problem is, how else could Ajay put the memory stick in the bust? A memory stick like that is enormous and have you seen how small the hole was in the Six Napoleons? It was enough for a pearl but a memory stick? No.
I usually tend to forgive such gaffes because I don’t see how else anyone could hide a memory stick in such a hurry. I close my eyes and think *suuuuure*.
But let’s forget our suspension of disbelief for a second.
What happened on screen cannot be real. There is absolutely no reason someone would see a memory stick and think ‘oh what a MARVELOUS IDEA! Let’s hide it in the bust anyway! I LOVE treasure hunting!’
So either you take a Doylist approach and say ‘plot convenience! let’s not overthink this’ or you choose the watsonian approach and ‘well… this scene is fake, right? It cannot be real’ and we’re back in EMP.
Anyway, let’s go back to yesterday’s heart vs head conundrum and see where we’re going with this. Irene hid her phone in a safe whose code was her measurements. Her heart was hidden in her body/her chest whose security was quite deadly. So far, so good.
The memory stick/lesser version of the brain was hidden in the bust of a really hated women (in the show) and the defense of said bust was ridiculous.
By showing herself naked to Sherlock, without any disguise, she revealed the safe’s code. The safe is her true self, without any pretense, any disguise.
Similarily, the bust shows Mary’s real self. Past the perfume, the disguise she puts, we finally see her true self.
Speaking of Thatcher. Margaret, like Greta has quite an interesting etymology: it comes from Greek μαργαριτης (margarites) meaning “pearl”. The only real pearl was Thatcher all along -and
Greta Bengtsdotte the most dangerous spy in the world, in other word, Mary- so Mary=Greta=Margaret=Thatcher.
YES!! Again, it TOTALLY works on the metaphorical level! And bonus, it reinforces the connection between “mary” and thatcher, ie, in case anyone hadn’t already picked up on those qualities (homophobia, heteronormativity).
and on a mirroring level, Sherlock/Ajay hides his brain-self in his sociopath facade/”mary”, but then he smashes the facade/bust to reintegrate. That’s not a simple process, hence the “chase to morocco” etc. I think Sherlock is still trying to figure out whether John wants the “real” Sherlock or the facade, and that kind of hiding oneself is a difficult habit to break.
Thank you for the wonderful additions @impossibleleaf@sarahthecoat Tracing a deeper level is indeed much more interesting and plausible than the surface reading – especially regarding that flashdrive business. And let’s not forget this isn’t the first time the contents of a flashdrive loses its meaning from one moment to the next. Just the same happens with the oh so important ‘Bruce Partington Plans’ in TGG. Jim throws them into the pool …. done and forgotten. :))) Flashdrive and brain is an excellent comparison I think. The AGRA flashdrive is hidden inside a ‘head’ after all …. the head of Thatcher=brit.Government=Mycroft=BRAIN …. and according to Mycroft in TAB (therefore Sherlock himself) Mary secretly works for Mycroft … for the BRAIN …. the facade has been created by the BRAIN (on a metaphorical level).
And what an interesting coincidence that the meaning of Margaret is … ‘pearl’. :))))
The Emmys: “And here is Sherlock series 4. Look at this passionate moment of… friendship… between Sherlock and Watson as they… hold one another… for the first time… as friends.”
The Emmys: “And the winner is… Black Mirror! For actually having the balls to be gloriously queer.”
The Emmys: “And Sherlock gets nothing!”
The Emmys: “You fucked upppp.”
4 for you Black Mirror, 4 for you, you go Black Mirror… and none for Sherlock Weiners
^^^ that was exactly what I was thinking when i wrote the original post
I’m a psychology major in my forth year at Uni. I am writing my senior research paper on fanfiction… stay with me for a moment. I want to study the effects of writing fanfiction and having a deeper connection with people/characters than the average fan, mostly to see if there’s any sort of stress relief involved.
What I need are volunteers to fill out a brief survey, nothing too long or invasive. I have not prepared anything yet because I am not sure if there are enough people who would want to participate. If you are interested, please send me a message, or if you know someone who might be, please reblog.
Help a fellow fan girl out.
Edit: I honestly didn’t expect this many volunteers so I just want to quickly thank everyone who has responded. If I haven’t messaged you back, I do apologize. To be honest I’m just a lazy shit and that’s my only excuse.
I do want to specify that I am looking for people of college age or older for this as of right now. Also I will be sending out the survey (hopefully) within the next week (as of 9/19/17) However, I am still looking for more volunteers so please if you’d like, shoot me a message.
The transition after the entire ‘John affair reveal’ is Lady Smallwood saying ‘This is absolutely ridiculous and you know it!’ after being falsely accused of treason, so do with that what you will.