Welcome to the second installment of the TJLC Month in Review! For outside reasons, this edition covers both March and April of 2018. Questions, comments, and additions are welcome! Please check the About page (below) first.
TJLC Month in Review FAQ
Read the previous edition (February)
People Are Talking About…
@garkgatiss discussed Sherlock’s 5-act structure, Bond, and Hannibal to explain how S4 contributes to the writers’ broad objective of fixing misinterpretations of Holmes and homophobic tropes. Once you’ve read it, here’s some commentary on 5-act structure.
@green-violin-bow explained how the idea of “historiographic metafiction” helps us make sense of S4 and the show’s overall structure.
Fandom News
Sherlock Holmes and the Adventure of the Furtive Festivity, an upcoming Johnlock short film, dropped a new trailer.
Miss Sherlock, a new Japanese femlock show, is out! You can learn about it here, watch the trailer here, and watch episodes here or here.
The scripts for THoB, TRF, TEH, and TLD are now available. Analyses of the THoB script here and here by @watsonshoneybee
Meta about Season 4 Only
On Sherlock’s vow, Mary’s death, and John’s motivation for pushing him away, by @tjlcisthenewsexy and @thesaltofcarthage
On Mozart’s music in TLD, by @tjlcisthenewsexy
Meta about Any/All Seasons
On John’s character in S3 and S4, by @watsonshoneybee
On name-calling that Sherlock receives, by @foxestacado with a neat diagram by @obotligtnyfiken
On the smiley’s significance, by @shinka with additions by me
On Mary Morstan and Birdy Edwards from “The Valley of Fear,” by @finalproblem
On the significance of “he saved my life but he couldn’t touch me,” by @witch-lock
On Sherlock’s falls and determinism, by
@tjlcisthenewsexy,
with additions by @raggedyblue.
On the line “poetry or truth,” by @raggedyblue and @ebaeschnbliah
On examples of mirroring between John and Molly, by @green-violin-bow
On contradictions in the Holmes family dynamics, by @gosherlocked, @ebaeschnbliah, and others
On gender assumptions as plot twists, by @skcolicity
On clowns, by @ebaeschnbliah, @raggedyblue, @tendergingergirl, and @possiblyimbiassed
A meta series on the media’s role in the show, by @possiblyimbiassed:
Part I Part II
A meta series on an EMP reading of Sherlock’s drug use, by @possiblyimbiassed: Intro Part I Part II Part III
On the phone-as-heart metaphor in THoB, by @sagestreet, with additions by @ebaeschnbliah and @possiblyimbiassed
New thoughts on ASiP and TBB, by @may-shepard, with additions by @devoursjohnlock, @out-of-the-subtext, and others
On parallels between Irene and Mary’s “deaths”, by @watsonshoneybee
On palaces, architecture, and EMP, by @ebaeschnbliah and many others
On the possibility of a chemical metaphor, by @ebaeschnbliah, @sagestreet, and @possiblyimbiassed
On why Irene’s survival supports Johnlock, by @the-sign-of-two
On S4 and EMP, by @morethansherlocked, with additions by many others.
On Mary’s role in TAB, by @victorianfantasywatson
Meta about the Original Stories
On how association with the Aestheticism and other factors code Holmes as gay in the context of the Victorian Era, by @conan-doyles-carnations and @artemisastarte
On how terms of address in the canon reveal characters’ relationships according to the customs of the time, by @artemisastarte, @educatedinyellow, and others.
On Holmes’s nerves and Victorian manhood, by @artemisastarte
On Sherlock’s class background, by @artemisastarte, @educatedinyellow, and @plaidadder
On Mrs. Hudson’s status, by @artemisastarte
Intertextual Meta
On parallels between James Bond, Vesper, and ASiB (plus, a wonderful complement to @garkgatiss’s new meta), by @bug-catcher-in-viridian-forest
On consequences and Doctor Who, by @tjlcisthenewsexy, @possiblyimbiassed, and @raggedyblue
On Sherlock and Jane Eyre, by @gosherlocked
On Watson and the Shark, by @teapotsubtext and me
Mini Meta
Cast & The Powers That Be
Martin Freeman gave a few interviews. This one goes over his career, but the real controversy came over this one, in which he supposedly said that Sherlock isn’t fun for him anymore. He specifically refuted this as a false interpretation of what he said here and here. @artemisastarte commented on why we should take the original interview with more than a few grains of salt.
Miscellaneous
Apparently, the first TJLC meta came out before the show even aired!
Our “bisexual lighting” meta made BBC News!
Back from the Dead
An old LSiT post on mirroring in TSoT has sparked new discussion.
@iwantthatbelstaffanditsoccupant added new thoughts to a discussion of who shoots John.
LSiT tweeted about why it’s good to move past the idea of an ARG.
@weeesi‘s classic, must-read series on queer coding in the canon is making the rounds again.
Coming Soon
@devoursjohnlock is continuing a meta series on The Hound of the Baskervilles.
@garkgatiss is preparing the fourth installment of the Poetry or Truth series. Haven’t read parts 1-3? Check them out here.
@possiblyimbiassed is continuing a meta series on an EMP reading of Sherlock’s drug use; start here.
@waitedforgarridebs in preparing the next installment of the Game Theory series; check out previous installments here.
Did you write some cool stuff that I missed? Drop me a message and I’ll stick it in next month’s review. Check out the About page first.
Tags under the cut.
If you would like to be tagged or would like me to stop tagging you, please let me know.
Keep reading