It comes to me in waves of sad what BBC Sherlock could have been and then what it ended up being. I keep thinking I’ve processed it, and then another wave of regret? nostalgia? wishful thinking? hits me. I would never have started watching this show if I knew The Final Problem was going to be where it ended up. God, remember how amazing S1 and S2 were? The episodes crackled with life and energy, and dare I suggest it, sexual tension between the leads. I had never seen anything like it. S3 got goofy, and TAB was a real head scratcher, but it was still recognizable as Sherlock. S4 just ruined it all for me. I can only think S1 and S2 were a happy accident. Despite themselves, the showrunners managed to make magic without even realizing it.
So, I try to let S4 exist in some parallel dimension, some fever dream or mind palace romp that has nothing to do with the edgy, exciting, dripping with meaning universe of broken, but evolving people who CARE goddamn it. They care so much it twists them up, just like we the fandom CARED.
So I’m going to keep caring about this universe and these characters, but I’m going to find the fan-made extensions, the stories and art and vids that make stories that MEAN something out of the mess that BBC Sherlock left us with.
You have put in to words what has been rattling around in my head for a few weeks now. As far as I am concerned season 4 never happened, (unless someone is writing a fix-it for it.) These characters are ours now. The show runners abused them and denied them the love, and happy ending that they deserved – so we will. A thousand times over, our Sherlock and John will find peace and more importantly, each other.
*hugs*
I have complete faith in this fandom, and that we will continue to do what we do best.
Reblogging in love of fix-its! We need them!
This is exactly what I said in my 4,500 word reaction post to series 4, the day after TFP aired:
I’m emotionally exhausted by all of this, but relieved that the series is over, because I was frankly dreading it, apparently for good reasons. At least I know now what I’ll be busy fixing for the next three years, or possibly forever if they never make another series. Mission: accepted. And now my watch begins. As I said the other day, this is why we here in this fandom exist: because the canon will end someday, and after that, their world belongs to us.
Someday, at some point, they will stop creating canon. And upon that day, we inherit these characters. We will always, always have the last word. Speaking for myself, at least, I plan on having quite a few of those. Suck it, Moftiss. The sad truth is that we’re better than they are. They could have built something great if they’d only gotten their tongues out of their cheeks and their heads out of their own asses, but instead they decided to kill the central element of any incarnation of Sherlock Holmes, which is always, always the dynamic with John Watson. They pushed it severely off-centre with the introduction of Mary, then made it worse and worse and worse in ways that were by no means necessary or even understandable at times. It’s as though they meant to. It’s sad. I’ve been depressed since series 4 aired. But damn it, I will do my small part in righting this mess, along with leagues of my talented colleagues. Not for them: for us.
It’s weird because just when I think I’m done being angry about S4, I get sucked back in.
I’m angry that Mark and Steven made no effort to ensure that their writing made sense. Beta reader. Editor. Script doctor. Anything at all would have given them some kind of objectivity on where they were failing the narrative.
I’m angry that the production values were shit. So many continuity errors. Set issues. Prop issues. The lamest fucking explosion effects I’ve ever seen (seriously, after going to the trouble of debunking the fan theory that Sherlock jumped from Barts into the lorry with the washing bags because the “angle was too steep”, we get “Boop, and they’re fine”?) And everyone was fucking orange. Seriously, given the money I personally have contributed to this production, I would have thought they had the budget at least do as well as they did before? If money was that tight, a fucking GoFundMe would have hit its target in hours, right? I’d have been happy to bung in a couple hundred bucks so Sherlock didn’t look like he was using Trump’s spray tanner.
I’m angry because I am a fan of the most famous detective in English literature, and they gave me a season full of red herrings, nonsensical details and meaningless “clues” and then got mad at me for noticing.
And I’m angry about that. I’m angry that they played us. They INVITED the fandom to engage. They embraced and they teased and they told us how much they loved us. And then when any of us–shippers or not–had the audacity to ask WHY about S4, we got gaslighted. I’m not advocating cyberbullying, at all. But why would you block and insult the people who helped make your show a hit when they express confusion about where the show has gone? They WANTED us to be this invested. But suddenly we were no longer their audience. We became bizarre social rejects who can’t take a joke.
Oh, and I’m really angry about the queerbaiting. I’m angry about the shitty portrayals of women. Every fucking one of them. I’m angry about the lily white cast. And the complete waste of Rupert Graves and Toby Jones. And Sacha Dawan. And Lars Mikkelson, come to that.
I fell in love with Sherlock, so I didn’t expect to get a sad Spectre/Saw/Silence of the Lambs knock off that No Homoed so hard it literally broke the show. If Mofftiss wanted to audition to write Bond, they shouldn’t have wasted our time to do it.
So yeah, guess I’m still pissed.
…Also left cracks in the foundation they had laid out. Retcons and magicians are not needed in a Holmes adaptation, and I agree 100% about that Bond mess. Of course that’s what they were doing.
Apparently, the Vivala team did find a blogger after all. Her name is Sarah DOYLE….and in her article about vivala, she links to an article on the BBC site.
@worriesconstantly
It is indeed related, if we pull the right strings.
who here remembers watching tfp in full russian on saturday. that was the most fun i’ve ever had in my life… i don’t think i ever laughed harder at anything than i did at umbrella sword. then i straight dissociated and i’m not 100% sure whether i’ve stopped
Imagine Sherlock giving his name at Starbucks and occasionally they’ll get it right but most of the time it’s stuff like “Shirley” “Cheryl” “Sharon” and on one occasion he spent the day in a huff because they gave him a cup that just said “Shrek”