My Sherlock Meta Masterpost

notagarroter:

I figured it was time to make a handy reference guide to the metas I’ve written in this fandom.  I’ll keep this updated and post the link in my blog description.

Chosen Families and Natural Families
BBC Sherlock and the Queer Reclamation of Biological Kin, plus further discussion.

Pulp Fiction: Fantasy vs. Reality in BBC Sherlock
Another attempt to understand TFP in the context of previous episodes.

Revisiting TAB through the Lens of TFP
Repressed memories and the woman problem.

The Eternal Problem
A Meditation on Mortality in Sherlock S4

Is Caring an Advantage?
An inquiry into the role of empathy and love on BBC Sherlock

The Interpretation of Dreams
A Freudian reading of The Abominable Bride (part 1)

The Pleasure Principle and the Death Drive
Part 2 of a
A Freudian reading of The Abominable Bride


The (Annotated) Abominable Bride
My attempt to catch every ACD reference/Holmesian easter egg in the Sherlock Special.

Nothing Made Me. I Made Me.
Paradoxes of identity in the ShSpesh trailer.

On Sociopaths and Psychopaths
What is the difference, really?  I do some research.

Live and Let Live
How to Read Sherlock’s “Gay Jokes”

A Nation of Herbivores
Hospitality, Cosmopolitanism, and Nationalism in Sherlock.

Sherlock and Paradise Lost – part i, part ii, part iii
A collage of verse and images illustrating the parallels between the texts.

The Missing Reichenbach Solution
Will we ever find out what “really” happened?  First in a series of
three metas approaching S3 from a deconstructionist perspective.

Deerstalkers and Doppelgangers
Will the real Sherlock Holmes please stand up?  Second in a series of
three metas approaching S3 from a deconstructionist perspective.

The Reconstruction of Sherlock Holmes
Sherlock critiques performativity. Third in a series of three metas approaching S3 from a deconstructionist perspective.

Molly Hooper and The Science of Attraction
Molly
Hooper is conducting a series of scientific experiments on Sherlock
Holmes.  I imagine what her lab notebook might look like.

The Work vs The Game
Perceptions of Labor and Leisure in BBC Sherlock

Sherlock Gives Excellent Head: A Trash Meta
What really happened with Janine behind closed doors?

How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love Season 3
When television reflects our own worst selves back at us.

Sherlock Is Actually a Girl’s Name
A bit of a rant on mortality, remembrance, and the tarmac scene. Also, further comments on Mary’s role.

A Book That Everyone Would Own
Why does Sherlock have an out-of-date textbook on syphilis?

Sherlock and Mother Courage
A booklock meta on sentiment and radical politics in Sherlock.

Sherlock’s Bookshelves
A collection of mini-metas on visible books in 221b.

The Sign of OT3
An examination of the complex relationship between John, Sherlock, and Mary, and what it says about modern marriage.

The Temptation of Sherlock Holmes
Moriarty, John, and Sherlock’s moral choices.

Sherlock, Cinematography, Sex, and Gender
On the way BBC Sherlock sexualizes Sherlock and challenges traditional gender conventions.

Feminism and Film Studies
A response to a very interesting ask about how to read 70s feminism in a
contemporary context.  Only tangentially Sherlockian, though.

Reichenplot: The Videotaped Solution
My attempt to make sense of Sherlock’s Reichenbach explanation in TEH.

Christmas in July
An examination of every time Sherlock and Mycroft mention Christmas.  Plus a follow up: Further Thoughts on Holmesian Christmas 

Would You Still Want to Help Me?
A brief meditation on Molly Hooper and why she matters.

Sherlock and Motherhood
Some brief thoughts on the role motherhood does (and doesn’t) play on Sherlock.

(see below the cut for links to mini-metas and comments on other people’s metas)

Keep reading

The Final Problem – Meta Masterpost

the-sign-of-tea:

A collection of meta people have written on Sherlock S4E3: The Final Problem. Wank-free and conspiracy-free, not focused on
shipping.

Riddles and explanations


“The song is the answer.” by finalproblem

“Sixteen by six, brother.” by finalproblem

Eurus’s
messages were pre-recorded


by urbanhymnal


How did John get out of the well?

by madeinrome


John and
the bones in the well
– comments by several people


Why were there no bombs in Molly’s
house?

by theleftpill

Relationships

Mycroft
and Sherlock in TFP
by earlgreytea68

Sherlock isn’t actually a girls’ name and Mycroft wasn’t a rubbish Lady Bracknell by anarfea

The Holmes siblings in TFP (Sherlock, Mycroft, Eurus) by mizjoely

How Mycroft addresses John

by thediogenes and codenameantarctica

Eurus and Sherlock’s Relationship
and the Game
by strawberrypatty

Play you, but who is Sherlock Holmes? (Sherlock and Eurus) by impossibleleaf

The violin duet (Sherlock and Eurus) by brokenwings221b

Eurus and Moriarty by weweremadeforeachothersherlock

Molly as Sherlock’s escape by fangirlhani

Sherlock
and John in the final scenes of TFP
by chitarra10

Characterization: Motivations

John’s behavior when
Sherlock threatened to shoot himself
by areteisjohnlocked

An analysis of Eurus

by urbanhymnal

Why Mycroft decided to sacrifice himself by almecria

Eurus’s influence on
Moriarty

by dynamics-of-an-asteroid

Two meta in one (about Eurus and Moriarty) by solrosan



Why Eurus didn’t kill Mycroft by theleftpill, anarfea and
rectorredux


Mycroft and legwork by dawningday84



Eurus can’t deviate from her
“script”
by notagarroter and anarfea

The violin scene – comments by several people

Why did Sherlock hand the gun to
Mycroft first?
– comments by several people and more comments here

Why did Mycroft continue to lie about Victor Trevor? – comments by several people

Reasons for Eurus’s silence by notagarroter

Characterization: Psychology

Psychosis as
a diagnosis for Eurus
by
sweeter-than-cynicism and fffinnagain


Sherlock and autism

by chitarra10


Moriarty’s behavior in TFP by dynamics-of-an-asteroid



Eurus’s
feelings about Sherlock and Mycroft after TFP
by eastwiind



Sherlock’s first cases by likingthistoomuch and mychakk


Deeper meanings and analysis



The Final Problem: Making Sherlock Holmes a good man
by
fffinnagain

and
an addition to the post by vulgarweed


Wilde At Heart, or, I Thought You Liked My Lady Bracknell (subtext/coding)

by plaidadder


“I made me” vs. “Eurus made you”: some rambling and likely incoherent thoughts on this apparent contradiction by

unreconstructedfangirl and
What this says about Mycroft by anarfea

Plane metaphor vs. water metaphor – comments by several people

Parallels between TFP and other episodes


The Landing (TAB) by doctorstrangebatch


Henry and the Hound (THoB) by the-consulting-strange-vidder

Bond Air and the airplane metaphor

(ASiB) by notagarroter

Filming and cinematography


Visualizing emotion with light and shadow by half-past-chaffinch


Sherlock Four (report of the violin
coaching)

by earthobservingsystem

Funny stuff and crack meta

The unfuckable rug – comments by several people

“Christmas present” or “Christmas Present”? by finalproblem

“She just locked him in her old cell.” by finalproblem


My other meta masterposts: