I’m a multishipper, and I love all the characters in Sherlock, including the women. Which means that I read a metric shit-ton of fanfic, of all ships. And Johnlock is the only pairing that tears down, disparages, and ridicules any of the characters on the show – and all of those characters are women.
When I’m reading a Johnlock fic for the first time and Molly or Mary are introduced, I hold my breath: is she gonna be a prop? A punchline? Is Sherlock going to be disgusted by her sycophantic infatuation? Is John going to despise her to his very core because she’s a murdering bitch? At every mention of her throughout the story, I read with tension because I’m never confident about how she’s going to be treated.
That really sucks.
It sucks even more for readers who want to give Johnlock a try, but who also love the women, and don’t want to read that sort of bullshit in their entertainment. Over the years I’ve seen several posts from people who honestly gave Johnlock a try, only to be repulsed by how viciously the women are portrayed.
Which really sucks, because there are so many amazing Johnlock fics, and series, and writers, who shouldn’t be losing out on readers because of this ugliness. And readers who are missing out on some of the best writing in the fandom because they don’t want to come across it.
So this blog will try to address that. I will be posting recommendations for Femfirmative-Johnlock* fanfics, for anyone who wants to read Johnlock without the misogyny or violence towards women. These are Johnlock fics that are “safe” for those who love the
ladies in Sherlock.
What does it mean to be a Femfirmative-Johnlock Fic?
- Johnlock is the primary pairing (duh)
- Female characters are present in the narrative in an active way
- Female characters have canon or reasonable personalities
- (Mary is not Eeeville; Molly is not pathetic and weak)
- Female characters serve the story, not work as a prop for the ship
- Female characters are not punching bags or objects of derision
Fics will be complete, so no rug-pulls will surprise you. Johnlock is the focus and the goal of these fics, not the women, so don’t expect a lady-heavy story. Female characters might figure heavily in the story, or might have only a few scenes throughout. But no matter how much or little they’re in the story, they’re treated as valid and as worthy as the
men.
This won’t be a hate blog. I won’t post links to ugly fics for shaming or any other reason, I won’t review hate-fics (those are easily identified.) I want to connect readers to fics they want to read, not fics to avoid. I’m considering including warning posts, for WIPs that start off Femfirmative but change course in the writing, or for so-called trojan horse fics, but I’m not fully decided on that yet.
I welcome recommendations from others as well: if you’ve read – or written! – a Femfirmative fic, please send me a link! I’ll read it through and post it if it meets the criteria. I’m happy to rec everything from multi-chapters to drabbles. I love finding new fics and new authors, and the more I have to post, the more everyone gets to read. Feel free to spread the word!
I hope I’m able to connect new readers with some of my absolute favorite fics, and find some new fics myself. Happy reading, everyone!
* – props to @mae-jones for the fantastic blog name! You nailed it, babe!