The Unfinished Act of Sherlock Series 4, The History of Adaptations It’s Working to Fix, the Larger Narrative of What’s Been Driving the Show, and the Real Final Problem.
Therapist: What about his brother? John: Mycroft? He’s fine. I mean, obviously normal and fine are both relative terms when it comes to Sherlock and Mycroft. Therapist: [Chuckles.] Obviously. But, I didn’t mean Mycroft. I meant the other one. John: Which other one? Therapist: You know, the secret one. John: Oh, that was just something… I said. I’m sure there’s… [He pauses.] How did you know about that? I didn’t tell you that. Therapist: You must have done. John: I really didn’t.
Images 1–5 above: From The Lying Detective, starting at approximately 1:02:58 Image 6: Zoom in on reaction of female agent in background when John first says the word “brother”
First of all, I need to make it clear that this catch—and it’s a great one—1000% belongs to @discordantwords. Not me. The only reason I’m building out a new post instead of reblogging the original is because when I saw the stills I went “Eh, maybe?” but when I saw the video I went “Woah, YES.” So this felt like something that needed a gifset.
Thank you for this @tendergingergirl! – in addition to the religious connotation of “vatican cameo” in ACD canon, we have an actual puppet, or a ventriloquist dummy materialized in the final minutes of TFP…
Which of course brings us all the way back to TGG…
But remember the twitter storm with Kermit the frog right before series 4 aired?
Fans have had a lot of issues with alleged inconsistencies in Sherlock Series 4–especially The Final Problem. Some I agree with, many I don’t, and others I’m undecided on or just don’t care about.
But there is one issue that, to my mind, carries more weight than any of the others.